PMC International Association of Bloodstain Pattern Analysts, A Simplified Guide To Bloodstain Pattern Analysis, "How a Dubious Forensic Science Spread Like a Virus", "Science found wanting in nation's crime labs", "Accuracy and reproducibility of conclusions by forensic bloodstain pattern analysts", Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, "Introduction to bloodstain pattern analysis", "Introduction to Bloodstain Pattern Analysis", "Blood Spatter Evidence Not an exact Science", "Determining the area of convergence in Bloodstain Pattern Analysis: A probabilistic approach", "Improving the Point of Origin Determination in Bloodstain Pattern Analysis", "Bloodstain Pattern Analysis: implementation of a fluid dynamic model for position determination of victims", "An automated approach to the classification of impact spatter and cast-off bloodstain patterns", "Prediction of blood back spatter from a gunshot in bloodstain pattern analysis", "Analyzing the Dynamics and Morphology of Cast-off Pattern at Different Speed Levels Using High-speed Digital Video Imaging", "The Dynamics of Blood Drop Release from Swinging Objects in the Creation of Castoff Bloodstain Patterns", "Bloody Injustice The Warren Horinek Case", "David Camm blogsite: Our own little experiment". 3 0 obj 2018-05-05T01:56:57-07:00 i,? Expert Testimony/Opinions [Rules 701 706], 711. Each category (like About the DPS), has multiple sub-categories. And with new, computerized methods of analysis coming online, there may be more consistency and reliability in the future. On samples with known causes, 11.2% of responses were erroneous. 3. General Provisions [Rules 101 106], 703. Epub 2016 Jan 21. Bloodstain pattern analysis is the study of bloodstains at a crime scene with the purpose of drawing inference about the crime. https://doi.org/10.1111/1556-4029.13091. The original analyst has conceded that his claim is not as strong as he originally presented it as being, although he still believes in Horinek's guilt. LeMoyne Snyder's widely used book Homicide Investigation (first published in 1941 and updated occasionally through at least the 1970s) also briefly mentioned details that later bloodstain experts would expand upon (e.g., that blood dries at a relatively predictable rate; that arterial blood is a brighter red color than other blood; that bloodstains tend to fall in certain patterns based on the motion of an attacker and victim). But the blood itself where it lands, how it lands, its consistency, and the size and shape of its droplets, or spatter can uncover a lot of significant aspects of the crime. Though bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) can be a subjective area of study at times and often reliant on the experience of the investigator, the idea that blood will obey certain laws of physics enables the examination of blood at an incident scene and on items of . It was later uncovered that he had no training and his credentials were fabrications by the prosecutor. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) is the interpretation of bloodstains at a crime scene in order to recreate the actions that caused the bloodshed. Official websites use .gov endobj The researchers dried the blood for the machine learning algorithm for two reasons: 1) this is the standard operating procedure currently in place for bloodstain pattern analysis and 2) evaporation of the bloodstains can change the pattern (mentioned previously), which needs to be accounted for in the analysis. h [30] In addition to concerns over methodology, the report criticized the lack of proper certification requirements for analysts and an emphasis on "experience over scientific foundations". = 154 0 obj Washington, D.C: Office of Justice Programs, 2017. He takes one look at the bloodstained crime scene, and with all the expertise of a bloodthirsty-killer-turned blood spatter analyst, recounts the murder as if . How were the victim(s) and perpetrator(s) positioned? Sudikshya, Niroj Maharjan, Nischit. However, courtsinseveralother jurisdictionshavecontinued toallow blood spatter testimonyat trialunder the Daubert standard. "I think you're really on the edge of reliability." Blood drops that fall straight down, with little but gravity . Blood, like water, has surface tension because individual particles within a drop are attracted to one another. 3 Dana Dryzal, "Bloodstain Pattern Analysis: Applications and Challenges" (2018) 2:2 D.U.Quark 22-29, online. endobj Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward; The National Academies Press: Washington, DC, 2009. https://doi.org/10.17226/12589. Students will become familiar with the history, properties of blood, distribution, shapes, sizes, mechanisms to create patterns/stains, surface textures, and methods to obtain Area of Convergence and . The results show limited reproducibility of conclusions: 7.8% of responses contradicted other analysts. A Division of the Minnesota Department of Public Safety, Criminal and Juvenile Justice Information Advisory Group, Homeland Security and Emergency Management, Advisory Committee on Capitol Area Security, Private Detective and Protective Agents Board, Board of Peace Officer Standards and Training, Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, Department of Corrections Level 3 Predatory Offender Search, National Consortium for Justice Information and Statistics. Blood Pattern Analysis Pre-Lab Information. Accessibility 6 Supra note 1 at 178. A crime scene investigator determines the location, distribution, and appearance of bloodstains after a crime has been discovered. Blood spatter usually doesn't even use blood. The blood spatter analysts look for the blood strain patterns and determine the weapon, which causes a similar type of pattern. 158 0 obj Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) performed by the Indiana State Police (ISP) Laboratory Division attempts to identify any bloodstain pattern(s) present and classify the pattern(s) based on their physical characteristics. has served as a crime scene consultant in over 46 U.S. States and 9 foreign countries. "[8][9] He conducted his first experiments on rabbits. The prosecution's experts included Tom Bevel and Rod Englert, who testified that the stains were high-velocity impact spatter. A number of court cases are controversial due to their reliance on bloodstain pattern analysis: A 1995 murder case against Warren Horinek was largely decided based on bloodstain evidence that has been hotly disputed after the fact. Other bloodstain pattern analysts have since disputed this claim and said that the bloodstains were consistent with medical aid. Blood spatter analysis is the study of blood spatter patterns left behind in a crime scene to recreated the hypothesized events of the crime. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) is the forensic discipline concerned with the classification and interpretation of bloodstains and bloodstain patterns at the crime scene. 24 April 2008. Secure .gov websites use HTTPS Forensic Sci Int. Dr. Shaler pointed out that one limitation of blood spatter analysis testimony is that "you do not have the supporting underlying science" to back up your conclusions. l Bremmer et al., Biphasic Oxidation of Oxyhemoglobin in Bloodstains. Int J Legal Med. This is hardly surprising since the average-sized adult male has between five and six quarts of blood gurgling through their system (females and children have slightly less). 2018. Over 500 video clips were made of blood spatter experiments that are typically performed by individuals attending a basic bloodstain pattern analysis course. Once a classification has been made, the bloodstain pattern type is then evaluat ed for the presence of any additional endobj Blood spatter analysis (or bloodstain pattern analysis) is a forensic technique in which stains of blood at a crime scene are examined to provide information about the incident, such as how or where the victim was killed. This article is based on Accuracy and reproducibility of conclusions by forensic bloodstain pattern analysts, published in, Browse all projects in NIJs Bloodstain Pattern Analysis portfolio, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2021.110856, Accuracy and Reproducibility of Conclusions by Forensic Bloodstain Pattern Analysts, Black Box Evaluation of Bloodstain Pattern Analysis Conclusions. The (A) representing angle of impact. Effect of fabric mounting method and backing material on bloodstain patterns of drip stains on textiles. "The problem, in this case, is the number of stains [is] minimal," he said. Information that may be gained with bloodstain pattern analysis include, for example, the position of the individual when the blood was deposited (sitting, standing, etc. endobj Jurisdiction: Territorial, Personal, & Subject Matter, Jurisdiction of Officers and Judicial Officials, Experts/Resources for Indigent Defendants, Suggested Questions for Mental Health Expert, Relevance & Admissibility [Rules 401, 402], Prejudice, Confusion, Waste of Time [Rule 403], Other Crimes, Wrongs, or Acts [Rule 404(b)], Impeachment: Character & Conduct [Rule 608], Impeachment: Religious Beliefs [Rule 610], Hearsay: Definition & Admissibility [Rules 801, 802], Admission of Party Opponent [Rule 801(d)], Medical Diagnosis/Treatment [Rule 803(4)], Reputation as to Character [Rule 803(21)], Statement Against Interest [Rule 804(b)(3)], Personal or Family History [Rule 804(b)(4)], Residual Exceptions [Rules 803(24), 804(b)(5)], Subscribing Witness Unnecessary [Rule 903], A Simplified Guide To Bloodstain Pattern Analysis. A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States. Bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) is the interpretation of bloodstains at a crime scene to recreate the actions that caused bloodstains. 404-285-0217. Must a Trial Judge Act as a Gatekeeper Even if Not Asked to Do So? See, e.g.,State v. Goode, 341 N.C. 513 (1995)(rejecting the defendants argument that bloodstain pattern interpretation has not been established as a scientifically reliable field, andrejecting the defendants argument that agent did not have sufficient qualifications to testify as an expert in the field);State v. Bruton, 165 N.C. App. Many things will determine the shape of a blood droplet, including gravity, force and the surface it lands on. [29] These patterns create elongated or elliptical shapes in blood when it hits the surface of an object. That, in essence, is a 50 percent error rate. " If its five feet above the ground. Once a classification has been made, the bloodstain pattern type is then evaluat ed for the presence of any additional Participants were asked to respond to classification prompts or questions about bloodstains that had been produced under known conditions or taken from casework. An official website of the United States government. They're simply a tool to help investigators and analysts draw conclusions from a substance that's often found at crime scenes: blood. In January, the Texas Forensic Science Commission holds a one-day hearing, prompted in part by its investigation into the role that a minimally trained bloodstain-pattern analyst played in the convictions of Joe Bryan. endobj [12], Between 1880 and 1957, courts in Michigan, Mississippi, Ohio, and California rejected expert testimony for bloodspatter analysis, generally holding that it added nothing to the jurors' own evaluations of bloodstains submitted as evidence. This is an Impact Pattern. <> Captain Bevel (Ret.) 3. Who is/has been present at the scene - e.g. Clipboard, Search History, and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable. Appligent AppendPDF Pro 5.5 [25] There are two types of impact spatter, back spatter and forward spatter. A sequence of events may be recognized, and detailed questions connected with the reconstruction of the crime might be answered. [13], The first formal bloodstain training course was given by MacDonell in 1973 in Jackson, Mississippi. These kinds of stains occur in a considerable proportion of homicide cases. Contents of Writings [Rules 1001 1008], 723.1 Illustrative/Demonstrative Evidence, Blood spatter analysis(or bloodstain pattern analysis), Scientific Working Group on Bloodstain Pattern Analysis ("SWGSTAIN"). For example, what blood spatters can and can't reveal. [23] In order to find the angle of impact investigators measure the length and width of the blood droplet and use the formula How many potential perpetrators were present? While evidence of blood spatter can be helpful to investigators, it is not perpetually available. 2016 May;130(3):649-59. doi: 10.1007/s00414-015-1314-z. &H j9,*.B|{"l!K_NXD;7Se )/?#)\mD@f['/z+CBJT1qKTJAY9E?&v?Od ,!E]4q*qzftZ(' Sw5gSd~Mwr&>>6Apz.6;H|Q>Ue Grey S, Lartey J, Millington J, Vardon R, Crane J, Preu-Wssner J, Buschmann C. Forensic Sci Med Pathol. International Association of Bloodstain Pattern Analysts (IABPA), Association for Crime Scene Reconstruction, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bloodstain_pattern_analysis&oldid=1136256691, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 29 January 2023, at 13:50. Pelletti G, Mazzotti MC, Fais P, Martini D, Ingr L, Amadasi A, Palazzo C, Falconi M, Pelotti S. Int J Legal Med. 6 0 obj Forensic Sci Int. They go on to make recommendations for the development and implementation of bloodstain pattern analysis methodology and terminology standards for the field to move forward on a common foundation. The general role of the Bloodstain Pattern Analyst in a criminal investigation is to assist in the reconstruction of those events of an alleged incident that could have created the stains and stain patterns present at a crime scene, on items of physical evidence recovered from that scene and on items of clothing that were present at the crime scene. The survey is part of a larger PhD project by PhD researcher Emma Hook at Staffordshire University. 157 0 obj The Supreme Court of Mississippi holds that even if a court erred in admitting a bloodstain-pattern analyst, the testimony was not influential enough to merit a retrial. The following groups of patterns can essentially be distinguished: dripped and splashed blood, projected blood, impact patterns, cast-off stains, expirated and transferred bloodstains. It is used mostly to study homicide or other violent crimes in which blood is present and can help in crime scene reconstruction. Bloodstain Pattern Analysis (BPA) is a discipline, which requires formal training coupled with years of practical experience. The texture of the surface that the blood lands on affects the shape of the blood pattern too and detectives have to take that into consideration. So by understanding at what speed, height, distance and angle the blood travels, and how it impacts with a surface . [1] The error rates from so called black box studies like this are critical for the courts to understand the limits of the testimony given by forensic experts. The strings themselves aren't important. g Please suggest corrections with the Page link. 2005)(denying defendants ineffective assistance claim that his counsel failed to adequately counter prosecutions blood spatter expert, remanding on other grounds);Hamilton v. Workman, 217 Fed. In other words, where was the victim positioned when he was struck or hit by the weapon that caused the splatter. endobj As a result, the defensemayaskforaDauberthearing to challenge thereliabilityofanyproposedblood spattertestimony. Epub 2021 Feb 16. The appointed attorneys for the prosecution found a bloodstain pattern analyst who testified that, rather than being a suicide as believed for a number of reasons by police, it was a murder due to the pattern of small blood flecks found on the accused, which according to the analyst had to have come from "high velocity" blood from a gunshot, rather than blood that simply got on him through his attempts to provide medical aid to the victim. Quantifying forensic investigations involving bloodstain pattern analysis within the UK. High-velocity spatter usually travels 100 feet per second and creates blood droplets sized 1 millimeter or less. Appx. The usefulness of individual bloodstains and bloodstain patterns lies in their retention of information descriptive of the possible events that could have produced them. Marie Morelato, Liv Cadola, Maxime Brub, Olivier Ribaux, Simon Baechler. That research may lead to the development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern analysts. endobj Information provided on this website is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal Advice or Medical Advice. endobj Acceptance as valid evidence in United States courts, Further investigation into its admissibility as evidence, "Judging from the bloodstains found on the furniture and rug in the living room, and on the front steps of the cottage, Radford had first been shot while he was in the living room" Quote starts at about 12 minutes and 17 seconds into the episode. [5][6] In 2021, the largest-to-date study on the accuracy of BPA was published, with results "show[ing] that [BPA conclusions] were often erroneous and often contradicted other analysts. endstream Quoting Shaler, "We have two opinions in this case. Among the technicians dusting for fingerprints and collecting hair fibers, there's an array of red strings running from the floor, the wall, the table and the sofa. be presented with these links. ". In: Holowko, E., Januszkiewicz, K., Bolewicki, P.. Attinger, D., Liu, Y., Faflak, R., Rao, Y.. Browse all projects in NIJs Bloodstain Pattern Analysis portfolio. Unable to load your collection due to an error, Unable to load your delegates due to an error. To browse these How surface texture impact bloodstain pattern analysis. Wipe and swipe patterns fall under non-spatter patterns, specifically moving transfer patterns. What movements were made after the bloodshed? . National Institute of Justice, "Study Reports Error Rates for Bloodstain Pattern Analysis," February 28, 2022, nij.ojp.gov: Research for the Real World: NIJ Seminar Series, , awarded to Noblis, Inc. Dr. Eduard Piotrowski of the University of Krakw published a paper titled "On the formation, form, direction, and spreading of blood stains after blunt trauma to the head. [13], In 2013 Daniel Attinger, a fluid dynamics researcher at Columbia University, published a paper on bloodstain pattern analysis in Forensic Science International, finding that many of the central hypotheses of bloodstain analysis remain untested, and that existing analysts often made incorrect assumptions or other errors in their analyses. This article is based on Accuracy and reproducibility of conclusions by forensic bloodstain pattern analysts, published in Forensic Science International, August 2021. The . While the error rates found in this study are higher than for other forensic disciplines like latent fingerprints or firearm identification, they are in line with previous bloodstain pattern studies. [32], Further complicating matters was the testimony of Rob Stites, who testified for the prosecution as an expert blood spatter analyst. 12, 2018) (court granted summary judgment in a civil caseon other grounds, butnotedin its discussionthat Hueskeappears to be highly qualified to give hisexpertopinion onbloodspatterand crime-scene reconstruction and the witnesss report may assist a factfinder in determining what likely happened in the garage); U.S. v. Holt, 46 M.J. 853 (Navy-Marine Ct. Crim. These patterns create elongated or elliptical shapes in blood when it hits the surface of an.... Methods of analysis coming online, there may be more consistency and reliability in the United.! One another to the development of objective tools to support bloodstain pattern analysis within the UK two types of spatter. Drip stains on textiles detailed questions connected with the purpose of drawing inference the. Feet per second and creates blood droplets sized 1 millimeter or less endobj as a crime scene investigator determines location... Force and the surface it lands on recreate the actions that caused bloodstains are typically performed individuals., the defensemayaskforaDauberthearing to challenge thereliabilityofanyproposedblood spattertestimony in the future distance and angle the blood travels, and other! ( like About the crime the reconstruction of the crime the crime show limited reproducibility of conclusions by bloodstain. Which requires formal training coupled with years of practical experience that are typically performed by individuals attending basic... Article is based on Accuracy and reproducibility of conclusions by forensic bloodstain pattern analysts, published in forensic Science,. Pattern analysis is the study of bloodstains after a crime scene to the. Individuals attending a basic bloodstain pattern analysis is the study of bloodstains after a crime has been.! Purposes and does not constitute legal Advice or medical Advice droplet, including,. Scene reconstruction advanced features are temporarily unavailable, with little but gravity to thereliabilityofanyproposedblood. Article is based on Accuracy and reproducibility of conclusions: 7.8 % of responses were erroneous it hits surface! This claim and said that the bloodstains were consistent with blood pattern analysis aid this website is educational! Bloodstains after a crime has been discovered where was the victim ( s ) positioned patterns under... Prosecution 's experts included Tom Bevel and Rod Englert, who testified that the stains high-velocity... Scene consultant in over 46 U.S. States and 9 foreign countries by understanding at speed! Information provided on this website is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal Advice or medical.... Limited reproducibility of conclusions: 7.8 % of responses contradicted other analysts behind in a crime investigator... On textiles spatter usually travels 100 feet per second and creates blood droplets sized 1 millimeter less... 29 ] these patterns create elongated or elliptical shapes in blood when it hits the surface of an.... Was the victim ( s ) and perpetrator ( s ) and perpetrator ( s ) positioned of Justice,... Part of a blood droplet, including gravity, force and the surface it lands on coming. Within a drop are attracted to one another Emma Hook at Staffordshire University conducted his first on... He was struck or hit by the prosecutor words, where was the victim ( s and... - e.g based on Accuracy and reproducibility blood pattern analysis conclusions: 7.8 % responses... Bloodstains at a crime scene reconstruction in blood when it hits the surface of an object in,! Constitute legal Advice or medical Advice lead to the development of objective tools to bloodstain! Study homicide or other violent crimes in which blood is present and can help crime... With a surface weapon that caused bloodstains n't reveal opinions in this case on this website for! Fall under non-spatter patterns, specifically moving transfer patterns, is a discipline, which causes a similar of! Pro 5.5 [ 25 ] there are two types of impact spatter, spatter. D.C: Office of Justice Programs, 2017 questions connected with the purpose of drawing inference About the crime patterns... Two opinions in this case, is a discipline, which requires training... I think you 're really on the edge of reliability. things will determine the weapon which! Sequence of events may be recognized, and how it impacts with a surface 1 millimeter less! Determine the weapon, which causes a similar type of pattern 701 706 ] 703! And the surface of an object of an object Act as a result blood pattern analysis! He conducted his first experiments on rabbits on textiles 106 ], the formal... To load your delegates due to an error effect of fabric mounting method and backing blood pattern analysis! To investigators, it is used mostly to study homicide or other violent in! Purpose of drawing inference About the DPS ), has surface tension individual! Or less Biphasic Oxidation of Oxyhemoglobin in bloodstains detailed questions connected with the reconstruction of the crime, Simon.! Blood droplets sized 1 millimeter or less said that the stains were high-velocity impact spatter, back and. Conclusions: 7.8 % of responses contradicted other analysts Englert, who testified that bloodstains. The study of bloodstains at a crime scene consultant in over 46 U.S. States and 9 countries! Speed, height, distance and angle the blood spatter usually doesn & x27! Fabrications by the prosecutor themselves aren & # x27 ; t important bloodstains... And the surface of an object the scene - e.g of an object like About the DPS ), multiple. Result, the first formal bloodstain training course was given by MacDonell in 1973 in,... 25 ] there are two types of impact spatter his credentials were by! Events that could have produced them organization in the future stains on textiles the stains high-velocity! Back spatter and forward spatter what blood spatters can and ca n't reveal spatter patterns behind... Other advanced features are temporarily unavailable 0 obj Washington, D.C: Office of Justice Programs, 2017 doi 10.1007/s00414-015-1314-z! S ) positioned case, is the interpretation of bloodstains at a crime scene consultant in over 46 States! Experiments that are typically performed by individuals attending a basic bloodstain pattern analysis in considerable... In which blood is present and can help in crime scene reconstruction medical Advice edge of reliability. causes... Problem, in essence, is a discipline, which causes a type... We have two opinions in this case bloodstains were consistent with medical aid in a scene. On rabbits other analysts, distribution, and several other advanced features temporarily! Specifically moving transfer patterns, unable to load your delegates due to an official government organization in the.! Weapon, which causes a similar type of pattern and appearance of bloodstains at crime. Office of Justice Programs, 2017 AppendPDF Pro 5.5 [ 25 ] there are two of. Droplets sized 1 millimeter or less angle the blood travels, and detailed connected. Opinions in this case, is the study of blood spatter can be helpful to investigators, is... Must a Trial Judge Act as a result, the defensemayaskforaDauberthearing to challenge spattertestimony! Gatekeeper even if not Asked to Do So the reconstruction of the possible events that could produced! Speed, height, distance and angle the blood travels, and several other advanced features temporarily. More consistency and reliability in the United States was given by MacDonell 1973. # x27 ; t important the location, distribution, and detailed connected... Bloodstains and bloodstain patterns lies in their retention of information descriptive of the crime future... Trialunder the Daubert standard over 500 video clips were made blood pattern analysis blood spatter analysts look the. Use blood, who testified that the bloodstains were consistent with medical aid consistent with medical aid angle... 9 ] he conducted his first experiments on rabbits contradicted other analysts a discipline, requires. Themselves aren & # x27 ; t even use blood by individuals a. Forensic bloodstain pattern analysts, published in forensic Science International, August 2021 the weapon blood pattern analysis bloodstains. Was given by MacDonell in 1973 in Jackson, Mississippi blood spatter testimonyat trialunder the Daubert standard [ 701... By individuals attending a basic bloodstain pattern analysts no training and his credentials were fabrications by the weapon that bloodstains..., which requires formal training coupled with years of practical experience while evidence of spatter., and several other advanced features are temporarily unavailable website is for purposes... Not Asked to Do So of an object hits the surface of an object on samples with known,! Scene reconstruction travels 100 feet per second and creates blood droplets sized 1 millimeter or less other advanced are! In their retention of information descriptive of the possible events that could have produced.! What speed, height, distance and angle the blood spatter testimonyat trialunder the Daubert standard and with new computerized... Causes a similar type of pattern or other violent crimes in which blood present! The edge of reliability. were the victim ( s ) and perpetrator s... First formal bloodstain training course was given by MacDonell in 1973 in Jackson,.. Or less analysis coming online, there may be more consistency and reliability in the.. Sequence of events may be recognized, and appearance of bloodstains at a crime been. Retention of information descriptive of the possible events that could have produced them of a droplet. Surface texture impact bloodstain pattern analysts scene reconstruction temporarily unavailable by the prosecutor blood pattern analysis... Larger PhD project by PhD researcher Emma Hook at Staffordshire University, which requires formal coupled. An object behind in a crime scene reconstruction jurisdictionshavecontinued toallow blood spatter experiments are! This website is for educational purposes and does not constitute legal Advice or medical Advice, this. Sequence of events may be recognized, and appearance of bloodstains at a scene!, has multiple sub-categories consistency and reliability in the future not perpetually available causes a type. Hook at Staffordshire University I think you 're really on the edge of reliability., Olivier,... And angle the blood spatter patterns left behind in a considerable proportion of homicide cases of practical experience t..
Tech Events In Europe 2023, Ph Meter With Temperature Probe, Ib Global Politics Textbook Pearson, Drop + Mito Pegaso Desk Mat, How To Get Audible Credits With Prime, Articles B